Canada condemns
genocide with its words, but does little to prevent it with its actions.
By Fareed Khan
The
international legal order along with the human rights of Palestinians under
Israeli rule and in the West are under assault by Israel and its Western cheer
leaders like never before as three foundational documents of the UN go ignored:
the UN Charter,
Genocide Convention and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
As the world
marks 10 months since the start of Israel’s genocide against Palestinians in
Gaza in response to the Hamas attack on Israel, we have to question whether
Canada’s leaders who often claim to be defenders of human rights and the
“international rule of law” actually believe in standing behind these documents
and treaties, and whether Canada truly cares about stopping genocide. Because
if Canada’s response to past genocides and current Israeli crimes in Gaza since
October are any indication the answer seems to be “no”.
Since its
election in 2015 the government of Justin Trudeau has often talked about Canada
being a “rule of law nation” and a defender of human rights. But such political
rhetoric is meaningless if his government does nothing to back that claim,
particularly as the world witnesses the Palestinian genocide with almost 47,000 Palestinians killed
by Israel as of mid-July.
In September
2018 the House of Commons and Senate made history when
they each passed motions with unanimous support declaring the atrocities
committed by Myanmar against the Rohingya in 2017–18 as a genocide, becoming
the first country to do so. Subsequently the Canadian government did little of
substance to follow it up with actions to stop the on-going crimes.
In February 2021 the House of
Commons passed a motion declaring China’s persecution of its Uyghur minority as
genocide. Of 338 MPs 266 voted in favour of the motion with the entire cabinet
but one being absent for the vote. Since then, the Canadian government has done
nothing of consequence, either on its own or with other like minded nations, to
help stop the Uyghur genocide.
In January
of this year the International Court of Justice
(ICJ) issued an interim ruling on South Africa’s genocide case for Israeli
crimes in Gaza calling it “plausible” that Palestinians were victims of
genocide. Twelve other countries have
joined South Africa’s case, including Ireland, and Canada’s NATO allies Belgium
and Spain, but not Canada. This is another instance of Canada doing nothing to
help stop genocidal crimes. Even a motion in the House of
Commons tabled by the NDP and supported by NDP, Bloc Quebecois, Green Party and
all but three Liberal MPs calling for a ceasefire and an end to Canadian arms
sales to Israel, hasn’t compelled the Trudeau government to act. Canada continues
to be complicit in Israeli crimes by selling Israel weapons.
Under the
Genocide Convention Israel is committing four of the five crimes against
Palestinians defined as genocide. By all appearances, these alleged crimes have
been perpetrated “with an intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national,
ethnic, racial or religious group”, including: killing members of the group;
causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; deliberately
inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its
physical destruction in whole or in part; and imposing measures intended to
prevent births within the group.
Even Jewish and Israeli academics
have signed letters and petitions calling Israeli atrocities a genocide.
Israeli scholar Raz Segal, a professor of Holocaust and genocide studies at
Stockton University, has called Israel’s actions “A textbook case of genocide”. And hundreds of
thousands of Jews in the diaspora have joined pro-Palestinian protests in
Western nations demanding an end to Israel’s assault on Gaza.
Signatories
to the Genocide Convention are legally bound to prevent the crime from
happening and also prosecute perpetrators. Canada has done neither in the
past, and has run interference at the ICJ
and the International Criminal Court in recent years by criticizing both courts
and interfering in their investigations into genocidal crimes committed by
Israel and its leaders.
Canada’s
failure to live up to its international legal obligations isn’t new. Along with
the Rohingya and Uyghur genocides it failed to act to prevent the Rwandan genocide, the Balkans genocide, the Darfur genocide, and now
the Palestinian genocide.
Claiming to
support the international rule of law and institutions that enforce it but
undermining each in the face of genocide is the ultimate act of hypocrisy and
racism by Canada, especially given that Palestinians, Rwandans, the Rohingya,
Uyghurs, Darfuris, and Muslims in the Balkans are non-white or predominantly
Muslim. It’s clear through their words and actions that Liberal and
Conservative governments have utterly failed to serve the cause of human rights
and international rule of law in the past, and especially right now when
Palestinians are facing genocide. They have only shown humanity for genocide
victims after the fact, and empathy and compassion for them only when
politically expedient. In doing so they demonstrate the deep racism of
Canada’s foreign policy, that Canada and its leaders don’t really care about
stopping genocide and seemingly never have.
Fareed Khan is the founder of Canadians United Against Hate and has written and commented extensively about issues around racism and human rights.
© 2024 Rabble.ca. © 2024 The View From Here. © 2024 Fareed
Khan. All Rights Reserved.
We live in a country that freely accepts genocide, and we live in a county where too many citizens would rather turn a blind eye than know the very ugly truth.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the great Article. I am always grateful for your perspectives and analysis.
Over the last 10 months Canada's political leaders have shown all Canadians that they are subservient to the interests of the fascist Israeli state and care little that the vast majority of Canadians oppose Canada's policies towards Israel and Palestine. They have also shown that they are heartless and without humanity to the untold suffering of Palestinians under the jackboot of Israeli oppression. Thanks for writing this because it needs to be said.
ReplyDeleteAs this genocide of Palestinians continues we are seeing very clearly that there is as racist hierarchy in Canada where Zionist fascists have embedded themselves at the top of the pyramid, and control the narratives which are decidedly anti-Palestinian and anti-Muslim. This has nothing to do with Judaism and I will do what I can in my small way to defeat the politicians who have allowed this inhumanity to be perpetuated.
ReplyDeleteJudaism does not condone what Zionists are doing to Palestinians. Jews are not a monolith and there are many anti-Zionist Jews who condemn Israel for its Apartheid state and the horrific crimes it is and has committed. The ones who stand behind and defend Israel are actually violating the teachings of the Torah and Talmud and are no better than white supremacist evangelical Christians. It is truly sad that they did not learn the lessons of the Holocaust and are doing to Palestinians what Nazis did to Jews. As it says in Genesis in the Old Testament: "And now you are cursed from the ground, which has opened its mouth to receive your brother’s blood from your hand. When you work the ground, it shall no longer yield to you its strength. You shall be a fugitive and a wanderer on the earth."
ReplyDelete