Lament For The Unremembered Dead: Why Are the Lives of 9/11 Victims Valued More Than of Those of Muslims Killed In The ‟War On Terror”

By Fareed Khan

 

I wrote the following on September 11, 2006, the fifth anniversary of the terrorist attacks on New York City and Washington DC, and emailed it to my list of email contacts in the hope that it would generate meaningful discussion.

 

For the vast majority of people September 11th will always be remembered for the images of planes flying into the World Trade Center.  For many of us, we will always remember where we were when the World Trade Center towers came crashing down.

There have been many events and actions that have taken place related to the issue of terrorism since that sunny September morning in 2001, and much has been written about this tragic event and its aftermath.  Some of what has taken place include the following: the United States launched its "war on terror" and invaded both Afghanistan and Iraq as a consequence; the threat of terrorism has been used to justify violating the civil liberties and human rights of Muslims in the U.S., Canada and many other western democracies; the American and other Western governments have spied on their citizens by monitoring their phone and Internet use using the threat of terrorism as a justification; the U.S. implemented a campaign of attacks by armed aerial drones in Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia, Libya and other Muslim majority nations in pursuit of terrorists despite the fact that thousands of innocent people died as a result; and more than a million innocent men, women and children have been injured and killed as a result of U.S. actions in Afghanistan and Iraq and elsewhere.

Related:
*  History of NSA Spying Information since 2005
*  Predator Drone Strikes: 50 Civilians Are Killed For Every 1 Terrorist
*  Leaked report shows high civilian death toll from CIA drone strikes
*  Casualties of the Iraq War
*  Lancet Survey of Iraq War Casualties
*  Civilian Casualties in the War in Afghanistan

While some of the numbers and statistics have changed, the words I wrote in 2006 are even more relevant today than they were when I wrote them.  Except now we are aware of the lies that were used to justify the invasion of Iraq.  We have seen hundreds of billions of dollars poured into the military campaigns in both Afghanistan and Iraq -- money which could have wiped out the national debts of the most impoverished nations in the world.  And we have seen the threat of terrorism used to justify a lot of unjust and illegal actions by governments around the world.

Source: http://www.motherjones.com/mojo/2013/03/charts-cost-iraq-war

Related:
*  Bush Lowballed Us On Iraq By $6 Trillion 
*  Estimated Cost of Post 9/11 Wars
*  Over 330,000 Killed By Violence, $4 Trillion Spent and Obligated

As you read what I wrote fourteen years ago, I ask you to question why it seems that the lives of those in western countries seem to have greater value than those of people in places like Afghanistan, Iraq and Pakistan.  I ask you to question at what point will the deaths of the 2,977 victims who died on September 11, 2001 finally be avenged.  And I ask you to challenge the rhetoric by the leaders of western nations about the sanctity of human life when their actions have led to the death and injury of hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of innocent Muslims in far off lands whose daily concerns and desires are no different than those of the average person living in the west.

Furthermore, consider that the annual recognition of 9/11 victims while ignoring the million plus Muslim victims of the US led war on terror is the epitome of western exceptionalism and Islamophobic bigotry. Because it shows that the American victims of this crime are more valued than the million plus innocent Muslims who were killed in the years that followed by the US and its allies in their wars of vengeance.

 

Those innocents killed by the US in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Pakistan, Yemen, Somalia and elsewhere were victims of a racist US foreign policy that destroyed nations, destabilized the Middle East and North Africa, created terrorist breeding grounds, led to the creation of ISIS, and caused a refugee crisis not seen since World War 2.

 

It's beyond time to recognize all the dead that resulted from 9/11 and not just the 2,977 Americans who died 19 years ago. Because to only memorialize the 9/11 victims and not the killing of more than a million brown people at the hands of western nations is criminal racism exemplified.

*********************

Lament  For  The  Unremembered  Dead

Why Are the Lives of 9/11 Victims Valued More Than of Those of Others Killed In The ‟War On Terror”

For the rest of our lives most of us will remember where we were on that September 11th morning in 2001 when we learned of the terrorist attacks taking place in the United States.  We will remember the images, we will recall our horror, and we will think of the sadness we felt for the innocent lives lost on that day.  And every year on the anniversary of that occasion, as the media gives us coverage of the memorial events and replays the images, we will be reminded again and again of what happened in New York City and Washington D.C. on that day.

But what about the innocents in other parts of the world who have have been killed since the 9/11 attacks as a result of the response by the U.S. and other western nations to the terrorist attacks – what about the ‟unremembered” dead?

The people I refer to are the hundreds of thousands innocent men, women and children in Afghanistan, Iraq, and other countries who have died as a result of the ‟war on terror” -- those who are antiseptically referred to by western politicians and military leaders as “collateral damage”.  Those who died days or weeks after they were injured due to attacks by military forces, government security forces, insurgents or terrorists.  Those who didn’t have access to medical attention to treat their injuries or who no longer had access to clean water or electricity.

What about these people?

These are innocent victims who will get no memorials.  Their deaths and life changing injuries are not and will not be an occasion for special annual media events or poignant documentaries.  There will be no commemorative speeches about them by political leaders.  We will not see the faces of their family members as backdrops for speeches by politicians.  And there will be few in the west that will remember them let alone mourn for them.

It is conservatively estimated that the west's effort to combat terrorists has directly resulted in the deaths of over 60,000 people world-wide (a gross underestimation according to some), created 4.5 million refugees, and cost the United States more money than it would take to pay off the national debts of every poor nation on earth.  This cumulative body count does not include those who have died due to the suffering caused by the destruction of civilian infrastructure (i.e. water/sewage treatment facilities, power generation plants, hospitals, etc.).

In Afghanistan conservative estimates for innocent civilian deaths range from 4,500 to over 15,000 in the military campaign to overthrow the Taliban and maintain support for the current Afghan government.  The fact that the Taliban were deposed has been a positive thing for Afghans but the fact that the blood of thousands of innocents was spilled in the process should be something that must be remembered no less than we remember the victims of 9/11.

In Iraq the website Iraq Body Count puts the number of Iraqi civilian deaths at between 41,650 and 46,318 since the beginning of the U.S. invasion to overthrow Saddam Hussein in 2003.  Where are the stirring memorials for them?  Where are the emotional speeches?  Where are the TV news specials that talk about the plight of the families of these victims?

All of these numbers do not include the injured taken home by their families who died weeks or months later due to their injuries.  If these numbers were to be added then the casualty figures would be in the hundreds of thousands.

Related:
*  Iraqi Death Toll: Why the U.N. Can't Count
*  Iraq's death toll is far worse than our leaders admit
*  Spray and slay - Are American troops out of control in Iraq
*  The Marine's tale - 'We killed 30 civilians in six weeks, I felt we were committing genocide
*  War blamed for 655,000 Iraqi deaths

So why is it that deaths of these innocent people do not register on the collective consciousness of society in the west?

On the surface the answer seems simple enough.  Unlike on 9/11, there are rarely cameras present to record the tragic deaths of these people.  And when there are cameras around, these images hardly ever make it into the news stories that we tune into on a daily basis.  Or the images are not dramatic enough to make an impact on our imagination.  After all what images from Afghanistan or Iraq can compete with the drama and the horror of planes crashing into skyscrapers, or of 110 story office towers collapsing.

But the true explanation may be more disturbing than most in the west care to admit.  The fact is that most in the west don’t want to know or be reminded of these other victims because to acknowledge and commemorate their plight and suffering would mean taking a long, hard look at ourselves.  Conducting this self-examination would make us see our own deep character flaws, admit that there is a racist tinge to public support for the war on terror, and might cause us to realize that western society is not as civilized as we believe it to be.

After all, how could a civilized society not be incensed when government policies or societal attitudes paint a whole culture or a world-wide faith as terrorists.  How can a civilized society not empathize with all victims of violence, whatever their ethnicity, nationality, culture or faith?  How can a civilized society only acknowledge and commemorate the 2,977 victims of one act of criminal violence while relegating the other 60,000 plus victims to the dark corners or our collective memory?

Yes . . . today is once again September 11th.  And yes, we should remember the victims of a horrific and criminal act by a group of zealots.  But let us also remember the tens of thousands (if not hundreds of thousands) of victims of this so-called ‟war on terror”.

SOURCE: The Guardian

Let us remember the face of a 12 year old Iraqi boy who lost his limbs as well as his parents and extended family when his family home was ‟accidentally” bombed by U.S. forces in 2004.

Related:
*  Iraqi bomb boy's anger at pilot
*  Armless orphan now in Kuwait for treatment
*  The unfortunate poster boy

Let us remember the scores of people killed in a wedding party in southern Afghanistan in 2002 when the celebration in their village was mis-identified as a gathering of Taliban insurgents and bombed.

And let us try and acknowledge the suffering and anguish of the tens of thousands of families in Afghanistan, Iraq, and other countries in that region of the world who mourn their dead in anonymity, without the attention of news cameras, without special ceremonies, without the presence of high powered politicians.

If we as a society can do this, then and only then can we rightfully claim the designation of a society that is compassionate, just, and civilized. 

Related Articles & Links: 
*  Collateral Murder 
*  Photos: Nine Years of War in Iraq 
*  Child Victims of War 
*  Iraq conflict has killed a million Iraqis: survey
*  Iraqanalysis.org 
*  Iraqi Children:Deprived Rights, Stolen Future 
*  In Harm's Way 

NOTE: All links in this article were current and working at the time of posting.  If any links no longer work please post a note and the problem will be corrected as soon as possible. 

© 2020 The View From Here.  © 2020 Fareed Khan.  All Rights Reserved.